About us
Why shop at The Toy Chest?
On the surface, we're a just another super awesome independent toy store (Indiana's oldest, actually!) with high quality, extra fun toys and expert staff. For 54 years we've been bringing you all the best in games, puzzles, dolls, crafts, science kits and more to encourage play in people of ALL ages.
But this isn’t just a store.
It's creativity.
It’s an experience.
It's a service.
It's people who want to know you and work for you.
What we really bring to the table is everything we can do to make your life easier and more fun. We build custom packages for every holiday. We personal shop for your birthdays. We know what kids want, and we make getting it easy.
To see what really makes The Toy Chest special, check out the "Personal Shopping" under "Shop by Category."
We can't wait to meet you and your family!
-Hilary & Emily
FAQ
Do we carry Sonny Angel or Labubu? No, we do not currently have either in stock.
What Jellycat do we have in stock? All of our Jellycat is listed on our website. Online Jellycat sales are limited to two of each item per person.
Do we have NeeDoh in stock? While in normal years we always have NeeDoh in stock, our shipments currently only last hours at a time. You are welcome to come in and shop our 10,000+ items any day, but unless you get very lucky, no, we do not currently have any NeeDoh in stock.
When will my order ship? If your order contains a custom package, they are prioritized by their deadline. This means a Boo Bag will arrive by Halloween, but a Birthday Box ordered two weeks after that Boo Bag might ship first if the birthday is in September. If you need your order earlier than the deadline you put on the order or earlier than the deadline implied by the holiday, just let us know, and we can push you up the line!